This week marks the start of something bittersweet: It’s the last season of my illustrious basketball coaching career.
(“Illustrious” might be a stretch: town league. But let me have this.)
I started coaching 10 years ago, when my son was in first grade.
Since then, I’ve spent countless evenings in middle school gyms that smell like floor wax and orange slices (okay, and a little bit like feet). This year, I’m coaching my daughter’s 7th and 8th grade girls’ team. She’s in 8th grade, so this is the last time I’ll coach her (or anyone).
Sad? Yes. Am I going to tear up at the end-of-season celebration? Also, probably yes.
But before any of that, we have a season to play. And every season starts the same way: figuring out what I’m working with.
At the first practice, I will watch closely, to see how capable the team is:
- Who can dribble with their nondominant hand?
- Who can make a layup, and who sends it off the bottom of the backboard?
- Who has a strong shooting form, and who does not?
- Who is ready to receive a pass, and who is putting her hair into a ponytail midgame?
- Who remembers to stand between their player and the basket when playing defense? (I know, the bar can be really low in town league basketball.)
Only after I know where we are can I decide what to work on. If half the team can’t make a layup, it’s not time to “put in the offense.” It’s time to work on fundamentals.
In this regard, the world of cybersecurity is not so different from middle school town basketball (granted, there is usually less crying). You can’t build a program on guesses … you need a baseline.
Which is why every time we start with a new client, the first step is a gap assessment – a thoughtful look at what security controls are in place, what’s missing, and what things should be addressed first.
Pick Your Rulebook
Basketball may be a single sport, but depending on the level at which the game is being played – town league, high school, college, NBA, etc. – the rules vary.
In security, the “rulebook” is the framework you assess against. Here as well, the right one depends on how mature you are and what your customers require. There are a ton of options, such as…
- CIS Controls. These “Center for Internet Security” controls are practical and prioritized safeguards that recommend different levels of security depending on where a given organization sits. If a client has no preference, this is our default.
But for companies just getting started, even the lowest CIS Control level – Implementation Group 1 (IG1), the baseline for essential cyber hygiene – is too much. Telling someone they have 85 things that need doing is not helpful. So for these clients, we have developed a custom, half-speed version, something we call Fractional CISO Foundations. - CMMC. If you’re in the Defense Industrial Base, this isn’t optional. It’s the price of admission for Department of Defense contracts.
- SOC 2. If you sell software or services to larger U.S. companies, their procurement teams will eventually ask for your report.
- ISO 27001. The international standard, and often what is asked for if your customers are in Europe or elsewhere overseas.
- NIST 800-53 Moderate. For organizations working with the federal government, or anyone whose market expects a more rigorous control set.
Many clients need the basics, but still want to begin with whatever framework their market demands. That’s fine. By assessing against that rulebook from day one, the work you do now counts toward where you are headed.
Why the Assessment Matters
A good gap assessment gives you three things:
- A starting point. You know what’s working and what isn’t. No guessing.
- Priorities. Not every gap is equally important. You need to fix the “can’t make a layup” problems before the “needs a better press break” problems.
- A way to measure progress. Six months from now, you can assess again and see how far you’ve come.
And here’s the good news: frameworks overlap a lot. Things like Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), asset inventory, backups, and access control show up in all of them. The work you do for one gives you a head start on the next.
And that’s important. Just as youth basketball skills need to be improved and adjusted as the players age, your cybersecurity program needs to evolve based on changes in industry trends, client requirements, A.I. impact, and on and on.
Build With the Future in Mind
At the end of this season, I’ll hang up the clipboard. But the girls will keep playing. They’ll take the fundamentals from this year to high school and (maybe) beyond, where somebody else will continue their development.
That’s the point of a good assessment. It doesn’t just tell you where you are today – it gives you a foundation to build upon for years to come. (Ponytail adjustments optional.)
Want to get great cybersecurity content delivered to your inbox? Click here to sign up for our monthly newsletter, Tales from the Click!